BEST Eyeliners

Have you ever admired the numerous and captivating graphic eyeliner looks that inundate platforms like Instagram and TikTok? Have you attempted to recreate those looks, only to be utterly disappointed? Rest assured, you’re not the only one facing this situation. While some of this disappointment could be attributed to not possessing professional makeup artist skills or being a beauty influencer, another significant factor is the quality of the eyeliner product you use.
After all, certain eyeliners can deliver crisper lines, longer-lasting wear, and overall superior results. But before you dive into scrutinizing your collection of eye makeup and comparing it to the highest-rated customer reviews, here’s the scoop: We’ve extensively researched and tested numerous highly-rated eyeliners available in the market. This effort simplifies determining which pen, pencil, or pot should be your go-to choice for your next eye-catching creation.

BEST Liquid Eyeliners

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Ink Liner

• Color : Black
• Brand : NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP
• Item Form : Liquid

SHOP AT AMAZON

---

Product Review

Indulge in flawless cat-eye elegance with NYX Professional Makeup’s Epic Ink Liner. This waterproof matte liquid eyeliner redefines precision and durability. Its ultra-precise, flexible tip ensures seamless application, accommodating every skill level. Each stroke flows effortlessly, delivering a defined finish that adapts to your desired thickness, from subtle to bold. The rich matte black hue remains intact throughout the day, resisting smudging and fading. Whether for a hectic routine or a glamorous evening out, this eyeliner’s resilience and intense color payoff make it an indispensable addition to your makeup arsenal.

NYX Professional Makeup’s Epic Ink Liner isn’t just about eyeliner; it’s part of a comprehensive eye makeup journey. From vibrant eyeshadow palettes to captivating false eyelashes, NYX offers an entire range for crafting gorgeous eye looks. With its precision and long-lasting matte effect, the Epic Ink Liner effortlessly complements these products, enhancing your eyes both intuitive and rewarding. What further elevates the experience is NYX’s dedication to cruelty-free beauty. Certified by PETA, the brand’s stance against animal testing adds a compassionate dimension to your makeup ritual, empowering you to create stunning looks that align with your values.

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Intense Pigmentation: The Epic Ink Liner is praised for its profound black color payoff, which creates bold and dramatic eye looks.
• Fine Brush Tip: The ultra-fine brush tip allows for precise application, making it easier to create thin lines, sharp wings, and intricate details.
• Waterproof and Long-Lasting: This eyeliner is often noted for its water-resistant formula that stays in place for extended periods, even through humidity and sweat.
• Quick Drying: The formula dries quickly after application, reducing the chances of smudging or transferring onto the eyelids.
• Smooth Application: The liner glides on smoothly without tugging or skipping, which helps to achieve a clean and even line.
• Affordable: The Epic Ink Liner is generally considered reasonably priced, providing good value for its performance.
• Versatile Styles: The precision offered by the fine tip allows for a range of eyeliner styles, from natural to bold and graphic.

Cons

• Brush Fraying: Over time, the brush tip may begin to fray, making it challenging to maintain the same level of precision in application.
• Removal Difficulty: While its long-lasting formula is a pro, it can also be a con to removal. Waterproof formulas often require specific makeup removers or more effort to take off fully.

Product Details

• This waterproof matte liquid eyeliner is designed to provide a flawless, matte black finish that stays put all day.
• Precise Tip: The Epic Ink Liner features an ultra-precise tip that is flexible and easy to use. Each stroke glides smoothly for an unbelievably fluid application, ensuring a defined and sharp finish.
• Customizable Line Thickness: With the precise tip, you can easily control the thickness of your lines. Lightly press down for fine and natural lines, or apply slightly more pressure for bold and dramatic looks. The versatility of the tip allows you to create various eyeliner styles.
• Complete Eye Makeup Range: Enhance your eye makeup game by pairing the Epic Ink Liner with NYX’s full range of eye makeup products. Explore eyeshadow palettes, false eyelashes, other eyeliners, concealers, setting sprays, eyebrow makeup, and primers to create stunning eye looks.
• Cruelty-Free Commitment: NYX Professional Makeup is a brand committed to cruelty-free cosmetics. Like all their products, Epic Ink Liner is certified and acknowledged by PETA as a cruelty-free brand. No animal testing is conducted during the development or production of their makeup items.
• Brand Exploration: The Epic Ink Liner is just one of NYX’s many professional makeup products. Experience a wide range of makeup options, including eyeshadows, eyeliners, false lashes, liquid lipsticks, lip glosses, primers, concealers, setting sprays, and eyebrow makeup, all designed to help you express your creativity.
• Ingredients: Water/Aqua/Eau, Propylene Glycol, Acrylates/Ethylhexyl Acrylate Copolymer, Laureth-21, Acrylates/dimethylamino ethyl Methacrylate Copolymer, C11-15 Pareth-7, PEG-40 Hydrogenated Castor Oil, Sodium Laureth-12 Sulfate, Sodium Lauryl Sulfate, Ammonium Acrylates Copolymer, Disodium Laureth Sulfosuccinate, Caprylyl Glycol, Butylene Glycol, Potassium Sorbate, Sodium Dehydroacetate, Phenoxyethanol, Sodium Chloride, Black 2 (CI 77266) [Nano].
• Usage:
• Shake well before use.
• Start by drawing a thin line along your lash line and gradually build the thickness as desired.
• Extend the liner slightly beyond the outer corner of your eye for a classic cat-eye.
• Allow a few seconds for the liner to dry before opening your eyes thoroughly.
• Packaging: The NYX Professional Makeup Epic Ink Liner comes in sleek and black packaging with white text, reflecting the brand’s modern and professional image.
• Net Weight: 0.03 fl. oz. / 1 ml

BEST Black Eyeliner

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Mechanical Eyeliner Pencil

• Color : Black
• Brand : NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP
• Item Form : Pencil

SHOP AT AMAZON

---

Product Review

The NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Mechanical Eyeliner Pencil from the Retractable Eye Liner series is a true gem for anyone seeking impeccably defined eyes with minimal effort. Its creamy, smooth formula makes application a breeze, effortlessly delivering precise lines and enabling seamless blending. The need for sharpening becomes a thing of the past – a simple twist reveals more product, ensuring consistent application without the fuss. As the day unfolds, this eyeliner proves its mettle by enduring heat, humidity, and long hours without smudging or fading. It’s the key to achieving that coveted winged eyeliner look that remains flawless from morning to night.

NYX Professional Makeup’s Mechanical Eyeliner Pencil is just an indication of their eye makeup offerings. With a diverse range of shades, from understated naturals to vibrant show-stoppers, your creativity knows no bounds. And it’s not just about the eyeliner – NYX provides an entire spectrum of eye makeup, including eyeshadow palettes, false eyelashes, concealers, setting sprays, and eyebrow products. Their dedication to cruelty-free beauty adds a compassionate touch to your beauty routine, ensuring that you can accentuate your eyes with a clear conscience. Embrace precision, creativity, and enduring elegance with NYX’s Mechanical Eyeliner Pencil and eye-enhancing products.

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Ease of Application: Mechanical eyeliner pencils are often easier to apply than traditional pencil liners, as they eliminate the need for sharpening and maintain a consistent, fine tip.
• Precision: The fine tip of the pencil allows for precise application, making it suitable for creating both thin and bold lines.
• Long-lasting: Many users find this eyeliner pencil has good staying power and can last throughout the day without smudging or fading.
• Variety of Shades: NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP offers a wide range of shades, allowing you to experiment with different looks and styles.
• Waterproof Options: Some variations of the Mechanical Eyeliner Pencil are waterproof, which is excellent for those looking for long-lasting makeup, especially in humid or rainy conditions.
• Cruelty-Free: NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP is known for its cruelty-free stance, so if you prioritize ethical cosmetics, this could be a pro for you.

Cons

• Breakage: Mechanical pencils can be prone to breakage, especially if the pencil tip is extended too far or if the pencil is dropped.
• Product Quantity: Mechanical pencils typically contain less product than traditional pencil liners. This means you may run out of products faster and need to repurchase more frequently.

Product Details

• Easy Application: Achieving the perfect eyeliner look is just a twist away. Say goodbye to the hassle of sharpening, as this mechanical eyeliner pencil allows you to twist up the product for immediate application effortlessly. This eyeliner offers unparalleled control, whether you’re aiming for a classic line or a bold winged look.
• Intense Pigmentation: The creamy formula of the eyeliner pencil boasts intense pigmentation that delivers a bold and vibrant color payoff. It effortlessly glides onto your eyelids, creating a statement-making look that stays put for hours on end.
• Long-Lasting Wear: Don’t worry about your eyeliner fading throughout the day. This eyeliner pencil’s smudge-proof and long-lasting formula ensures that your eye makeup remains intact through heat, humidity, and various activities, ensuring a flawless finish that lasts.
• Variety of Shades: Available in a range of natural to bright shades, the Retractable Eye Liner offers endless possibilities for creating diverse eyeliner looks. 
• Cruelty-Free Commitment: NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP takes a strong stance against animal testing. This eyeliner pencil is cruelty-free and PETA-certified, so you can enjoy top-notch makeup without compromising your values.
• Complete Your Look: Elevate your eye makeup game by exploring NYX’s full range of eye makeup products. From eyeshadow palettes to false eyelashes, eyeliners to concealers, and eyebrow makeup to setting sprays, you’ll find everything you need to create captivating and unforgettable looks.

BEST Maybelline Eyeliner

MAYBELLINE Hyper Easy Liquid Pen No-Skip Eyeliner

• Color : Pitch Black
• Brand : MAYBELLINE
• Item Form : liquid

SHOP AT AMAZON

---

Product Review

Are you struggling with smudged and uneven eyeliner? MAYBELLINE’s Hyper Easy Liquid Pen offers a solution. Its hyper-easy brush tip ensures a smooth, precise application that fits your eye’s shape. The revolutionary flex-tip brush and hexagonal grip provide optimal control, allowing stable, 24-hour wear without smudging.

MAYBELLINE’s Hyper Easy Liquid Pen No-Skip Eyeliner is more than just makeup. It’s a tool for self-expression. Whether you prefer subtle lines or vibrant pops of color, MAYBELLINE’s range of makeup products empowers you to experiment. Backed by New York City’s edge and innovative formulations, MAYBELLINE makes beauty accessible, offering effortless cosmetics to enhance your unique style.

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Ease of Application: The term “No-Skip” suggests that this eyeliner is designed to glide smoothly without skipping or tugging on your eyelid, making it easy to achieve a precise line.
• Precision: Liquid eyeliners usually offer more precision than pencil or gel liners, allowing you to create sharp, defined lines and various styles like cat eyes and wings.
• Long-Lasting: Liquid eyeliners tend to have better-staying power than other eyeliner types. They are less likely to smudge or fade throughout the day.
• Rich Color Payoff: Liquid eyeliners often provide an intense color payoff, creating a bold and dramatic look with just a single stroke.
• Quick Drying: Liquid eyeliners typically dry quickly after application, reducing the chances of accidental smudging.
• Versatile: Liquid eyeliners can create various looks, from simple and natural to bold and dramatic.

Cons

• Potential for Smudging During Application: Liquid eyeliners may smudge if you accidentally blink or touch your eyelids before they dry completely.
• Not Ideal for Smoky Looks: Achieving smoky or smudged eyeliner looks might be more challenging with a liquid eyeliner than a softer pencil or smudgy gel liner.

Product Details

• Hyper Easy Brush Tip: Say goodbye to uneven lines and shaky strokes. The Hyper Easy Brush Tip ensures a remarkably smooth glide along your lash line, adapting perfectly to the contours of your eyes. Achieve precise and even lines effortlessly.
• Flex-Tip Brush: Experience revolutionary control and stability during application with the Flex-Tip Brush. The custom hexagonal grip enhances your grip, allowing optimal control while applying the eyeliner—no more wobbly lines – just precise and controlled application.
• Long-Lasting Formula: This liquid eyeliner is formulated to stay put for up to 24 hours, providing intense color that won’t smudge or fade. Your eye makeup will look as fresh at the end of the day as when you first applied it.
• Versatile Looks: Whether you’re going for subtle elegance, bold smokey eyes, defined brows, classic shades, or a pop of vibrant color, the MAYBELLINE Hyper Easy Liquid Pen No-Skip Eyeliner is your versatile companion. Explore various creative eye looks with confidence.

BEST Retractable Eyeliner

e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner

• Color : Black
• Brand : e.l.f.
• Item Form : Pencil,Creamy

SHOP AT AMAZON

---

Product Review

Say farewell to lacklustre eyeliner and welcome the game-changing e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner. This waterproof pencil answers your liner prayers, delivering creamy, ultra-pigmented color that refuses to budge. From the morning hustle to the evening soirée, this eyeliner stays vibrant and smudge-free, defying even the harshest conditions. Whether aiming for a subtle lash line enhancement or a bold waterline pop, this versatile pencil can make your eyes pop, no matter the occasion. And for those seeking an extra oomph in their eyeshadow game, a beauty tip: use it as a base for dramatic, runway-worthy eye looks that captivate from every angle.

Even more delightful, this exceptional performance doesn’t come at the cost of your conscience. e.l.f. takes pride in its commitment to skin-loving ingredients, ensuring your beauty routine is toxin-free. Not only will your eyes look stunning, but you can also feel good about the ethical choices you’re making with a 100% cruelty-free and vegan product. It’s the embodiment of makeup that cares for your skin and the planet—the e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner isn’t just an eyeliner; it’s a transformative tool that redefines what makeup should be – reliable, vibrant, and conscious. Elevate your eyeliner experience and make smudges and fading a thing of the past with this revolutionary pencil from e.l.f.

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Convenience: No need for sharpening, just twist for more product.
• Portability: Travel-friendly, no separate sharpener required.
• Precision: Fine tip allows for precise eyeliner application.
• Less Waste: Reduces product wastage compared to sharpening.
• Variety: Comes in various colors and finishes for different looks.

Cons

• Breakage: Tip can break if handled roughly.
• Fine Details: Not ideal for intricate details.

Product Details

• All-Day Wear: Creamy, ultra-pigmented, and waterproof for lasting power.
• Intense Look: Use on the lash line, waterline, or lid for all-day intense eyes.
• Beauty Tip: Apply on the eyelid as an eyeshadow base for a dramatic, runway-style look.
• Skin-Loving Ingredients: e.l.f. Products are toxin-free, skin-friendly, and budget-friendly.
• Cruelty-Free and Vegan: Like all e.l.f. Products it’s 100% cruelty-free and vegan-friendly.

BEST Waterproof Eyeliner

Maybelline New York Eyestudio Master Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner

• Color : Black
• Brand : MAYBELLINE
• Item Form : Solid

SHOP AT AMAZON

---

Product Review

In the realm of makeup, discovering a product that effortlessly combines precision, longevity, and eye-friendliness can be daunting. Enter the Maybelline New York Eyestudio Master Precise All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner in No Smudge Black – a transformative gem that redefines eye makeup. This ingenious tool wields an ultra-fine tip, granting you the power to create sharp, defined lines that elevate your eye game from mundane to mesmerizing. Whether crafting an understated everyday elegance or a captivating cat-eye allure, this eyeliner’s precision empowers your creative journey.

Imagine a reality where your eyeliner remains impeccable through the bustling hours of your day – from sunrise coffee to twilight soirées. The Maybelline Eyestudio Master Precise Eyeliner brings this vision to life, lasting up to 12 hours without smudging, fading, or losing vibrancy. Moreover, Maybelline understands the importance of eye comfort. Dermatologists and ophthalmologists tested this fragrance-free eyeliner caters to sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers, assuring a gentle experience without compromise. With Maybelline, not only do you master the art of makeup, but you also embrace the essence of self-expression.

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Long-lasting: The eyeliner stays on all day, which benefits those with busy schedules.
• Quick drying: The eyeliner dries quickly, preventing smudging and reducing the chances of accidentally ruining your makeup.
• Felt tip: The felt tip applicator makes it easy to apply the eyeliner, especially for those with shaky hands or limited eyeliner application experience.
• Sharp tip: The pointed tip allows for precise application, making it suitable for creating winged eyeliner or other intricate eye makeup looks.
• Affordable: The product is reasonably priced, providing good value for its quality and performance.
• Portable: The compact size of the eyeliner makes it easy to carry in a purse or makeup bag, ensuring you can do touch-ups on the go.
• Waterproof: The formula ensures that the eyeliner withstands moisture, making it suitable for various weather conditions or activities.
• Available in black: The color option suits various makeup looks.

Cons

• Waterproof removal: The waterproof formula can sometimes make the removal process more challenging, requiring an effective makeup remover.
• Limited shade range: The product might have a limited shade range, which could be a drawback for those seeking various color options.

Product Details

• Ultra-Fine Tip: The Eyestudio Master Precise Liquid Eyeliner boasts an ultra-fine tip that enables you to create the sharpest, most well-defined lines with ease. Whether aiming for a subtle look or a bold statement, this eyeliner’s precision allows you to achieve it effortlessly.
• Waterproof Formula: Don’t worry about smudging or fading. This eyeliner features a waterproof formula that resists water, sweat, and humidity, ensuring your eye makeup remains intact and vibrant throughout your day, no matter the conditions.
• Long-Lasting Wear: Enjoy the confidence of knowing your eyeliner won’t budge. The Master Precise All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner is designed to stay put for up to 12 hours, granting you a flawless look from morning until night.
• Eye-Enhancing Color: Experience intense and rich color payoff that instantly defines and enhances your eyes. The No Smudge Black shade delivers a bold, striking appearance that complements a variety of eye looks.
• Dermatologist and Ophthalmologist Tested: Maybelline prioritizes your eye health. This eyeliner is dermatologist and ophthalmologist tested to ensure its safety for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.
• Fragrance-Free: Enjoy the luxury of fragrance-free makeup that doesn’t interfere with your natural scent or cause irritation.
• Maybelline Expertise: Maybelline New York is renowned for its expertise in eye makeup. Whether you prefer a natural, everyday look or a dramatic, attention-grabbing appearance, Maybelline provides the tools to create the perfect eye makeup looks.
• Versatile Range: Maybelline offers an extensive range of eye makeup products, including pencil and liquid eyeliners, highly pigmented eyeshadows, iconic mascara for voluminous lashes, and eyebrow makeup for perfectly defined brows.

BEST Ultra Black Eyeliner

Wet n Wild Mega Last Breakup Proof Liquid Waterproof Eyeliner

• Color : Ultra Black
• Brand : wet n wild
• Item Form : Pencil

SHOP AT AMAZON

---

Product Review

Dive into the holy grail of eyeliners with Wet n Wild’s Mega Last Breakup Proof Liquid Waterproof Eyeliner Brush Tip Pen. This gem is a steadfast solution to smudging, flaking, and fading liners. Its waterproof formula laughs in the face of tears, rain, and sweat, providing a near-indestructible hold. The ultra-fine brush tip offers unparalleled precision, allowing newcomers and experts to create delicate lines or dramatic cat eyes with finesse effortlessly. This eyeliner’s innovative tank delivery system ensures a consistent flow of intensely pigmented color, making application a breeze and delivering results that feel like a makeup maestro crafted.

Wet n Wild’s commitment extends beyond just stellar eyeliners. With a complete range of products, from bronzer to concealer, they’ve covered all your makeup essentials. The Mega Last Eyeliner fits into this lineup, completing your photo-ready look for any occasion. Not only does Wet n Wild prioritize your beauty, but also your values. Their cruelty-free status is a testament to their ethical approach, and for those who prefer vegan options, the brand offers a variety of vegan makeup and tools. Inclusivity lies at the heart of Wet n Wild – catering to diverse beauty needs regardless of age, ethnicity, skin color, or economic background. It’s not just makeup; it’s a statement that beauty is for everyone.

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Waterproof Formula: The waterproof formula is excellent for long-lasting wear, even in humid or rainy conditions.
• Smudge-Proof: The smudge-proof nature of the eyeliner helps maintain a clean and sharp eye look throughout the day.
• Precise Application: The brush tip allows for precise and controlled application, making it easier to create various eyeliner styles, from thin lines to dramatic wings.
• Intense Pigmentation: The product may offer intense pigmentation, providing a bold, vibrant eyeliner color.
• Longevity: The long-wearing formula may resist fading, ensuring your eyeliner looks fresh throughout the day without frequent touch-ups.
• Affordability: Wet n Wild is known for offering affordable makeup products, making this eyeliner an attractive option for those on a budget.

Cons

• Difficult to Remove: While its waterproof nature is a pro, it can also be a con for some people since waterproof formulas can be more challenging to remove completely.
• Drying Time: Some users might find that it takes some time to dry, which can lead to accidental smudging during application if you need to be careful.

Product Details

• Waterproof and smudge-proof formula for long-lasting wear.
• Ultra-fine brush tip for creating thin lines or bold cat eyes.
• Tank delivery system ensures even and richly pigmented application.
• Elevates your eye makeup with precision and elegance.
• Cruelty-free and vegan, aligning with your values.
• Wide range of makeup products available for a complete look.
• Inclusivity for all ages, ethnicities, and economic backgrounds.

Factors to consider when buying Eyeliners;

• Waterproof Formula: Look for smudge-proof and waterproof eyeliners to ensure long-lasting wear throughout the day.
• Applicator Type: Consider whether you prefer a pencil, liquid, gel, or marker-style applicator for your eyeliner.
• Color Variety: Check if the brand offers various colors to suit different makeup looks and occasions.
• Longevity: Opt for eyeliners with a reputation for staying power to prevent constant touch-ups.
• Price Point: Compare prices across brands to find the best eyeliner that fits your budget without compromising quality.

From ancient civilisations to today’s diverse range of options, eyeliners remain an indispensable tool for makeup and self-expression. Beyond their cosmetic function, eyeliners embody artistry and confidence, allowing us to convey emotions wordlessly. With evolving formulas and sustainability trends, eyeliners continue to innovate. Choosing eyeliner isn’t just about makeup; it’s about embracing individuality. Whether crafting a subtle everyday look or a bold statement, each stroke tells a story and accentuates personal style. So, let your inner artist flourish – pick up that eyeliner, adorn your eyes, and showcase the beauty that is uniquely you.